Articles hans_sophie_scholl

Published on December 2nd, 2013 | by Lauren Dunn

Being Young Is No Excuse: A Lesson from Hans & Sophie Scholl





I remember talking about abortion with our neighbor over the backyard fence. She seemed to agree tepidly with the pro-life position, but added that it wasn’t really her concern.

We’ll leave that to other people, she seemed to think.

In America, over three thousand children are killed every day by abortion.

Every day.

Every single day.

How is it that we, like our neighbor, have become so numb to this reality?

Where is our righteous indignation? Where is our passion?

But we are not the first to face this fight. Faithful pilgrims have gone this way before; we just need to find their footsteps.

Hans and Sophie Scholl

Adolf Hitler’s Nazi party left an unerasable mark on history.

Millions of people were killed because of their race, physical infirmities, or resistance to the Reich.

Why didn’t the local Christians work to save lives? Where was their passion?

Not everyone was swayed by Nazi rhetoric.

A young brother and sister, Hans and Sophie Scholl, found themselves at an impasse as they wrestled with the terror of the times and their place in it. Outraged but conflicted, the brother and sister, along with a few others, grappled with the risk that action would cause over the safety of conformity.

But conformity was never their priority.

We Just Don’t Know

When Allied forces liberated the concentration camp Ohrdruf, General Eisenhower ordered that the local Germans visit the camp to see the Nazis’ atrocities.

The citizens—including the mayor—were horrified.

Even though the evils had taken place so close to their daily lives, they were still shocked to the point of despair.

Just as many of them never knew the extent of Nazi cruelties, too many of us simply do not know the truth about horrific abortion practices.

No matter what procedure is used, a child is violently killed.

But there are always some who know.

In Nazi Germany, a few courageous youth could stand idle no longer.

Under the name the “White Rose,” some university students—included the Scholls—began secretly printing anti-Nazi pamphlets informing the German people of Nazi evils. Fewer and fewer German citizens could plead ignorance.

Out of Sight, Out of Mind

“Where does the truth lie?” Hans wrote to a friend. “Should one go off and build a little house with flowers outside the windows and a garden outside the door and extol and thank God and turn one’s back on the world and its filth?”

There must have been some who suspected that the Nazis were committing evil, but even these were sheltered from the victims’ cries.

Similarly, most of us are rarely near abortion centers, watching women walk in and then walk out, the irreversible deed done.

It is easy to forget the suffering of others when it is hidden from us.

It is easy to move sad and seemingly hopeless topics to the back of our minds.

But Hans knew that this was no option.

“Isn’t seclusion a form of treachery—of desertion?” he continued. “I’m weak and puny, but I want to do what is right.”

What Can One Person Do?

“Many, perhaps most, of the readers of these leaflets do not see clearly how they can practice an effective opposition,” a White Rose pamphlet stated. “They do not see any avenues open to them.”

How do you fight evil when it is protected by the authorities, celebrated in the media, and taught as right in the schools?

The courageous White Rose members understood that these daunting odds were no excuse: “We want to try to show them that everyone is in a position to contribute to the overthrow of this system.”

Hans felt a burden for proof of his beliefs—and action would be that proof.

“It’s high time that Christians made up their minds to do something . . . What are we going to show in the way of resistance . . . when all this terror is over? We will be standing empty-handed. We will have no answer when we are asked: What did you do about it?”

The White Rose used what abilities and resources they had to produce pamphlets and then distributed them to their closest audience: university students.

They didn’t win the war.

They didn’t liberate concentration camps.

But they did stand for the truth, and they were willing to face whatever consequences their stand might cost them.

And there were consequences.

A Higher Priority

One day a university janitor noticed the Scholl siblings frantically dumping out White Rose pamphlets to cover the university grounds.

On February 22, 1943, Hans and Sophie, along with another White Rose member, were executed.

They were 24 and 21.

But the fight was not over. And they knew it. Even as she understood how short her time was, Sophie realized what was at stake:

“How can we expect righteousness to prevail when there is hardly anyone willing to give himself up individually to a righteous cause. Such a fine, sunny day, and I have to go, but what does my death matter, if through us, thousands of people are awakened and stirred to action?”

Throughout World War II, lights shone out of the darkness of the Third Reich occupation. There was always a remnant who knew that standing for life was a higher priority than their own comfort—or even survival.

Still Standing

The war dragged on for two more years. The Scholl family, reeling from the losses of Hans and Sophie, as well as another son in battle, would never be the same again. Were their deaths in vain? Was their sacrifice wasted?

After the war, German citizens searched for a way to return to normalcy. Many who had been involved in the Reich now found themselves adjusting to life without Nazism. Among them was Hitler’s personal secretary, Traudl Junge:

Of course, the terrible things I heard from the Nuremberg Trials, about the six million Jews and the people from other races who were killed, were facts that shocked me deeply. But I wasn’t able to see the connection with my own past. I was satisfied that I wasn’t personally to blame and that I hadn’t known about those things. I wasn’t aware of the extent.

But one day I went past the memorial plaque which had been put up for Sophie Scholl…, and I saw that she was born the same year as me, and she was executed the same year I started working for Hitler. And at that moment I actually sensed that it was no excuse to be young, and that it would have been possible to find things out.

It’s a haunting phrase: “…it was no excuse to be young…” If Hans and Sophie Scholl determined to stand for truth and life—at their ages, in their difficult times—surely we can do the same.

What will we choose? To ignore the pain, hurt, and lies around us—or to pursue the truth and fight for life? The battle will be fought, no matter our stance. But will we choose the victorious side?

Our God never changes, and our charge still stands.

Our generation follows on the heels of many who have set the example in the fight for life. Their footsteps are large, and their legacy great.

May we be spurred on by those who have gone before, that great cloud of witnesses whose example inspires us to be faithful to what we have been called.

Where is our passion? It is there. We just need to be reminded that it is a righteous passion, and it calls for action.

Others may sit on the fence, but we know there is too much at stake.

hans_sophie_scholl_grave


Grave of Hans Scholl, Sophie Scholl, and Christoph Probst.








About the Author

is a writer and toddler teacher who can't remember the last time she read a book without highlighting in it or dog-earing it. Except for the ones from the library. She loves cookie dough ice cream, spending time with people, and seeing the clouds in the Midwestern sky. You can find more of her thoughts at These Traveling Days.



  • Barbara Mishkov

    I was always fascinated and in love with MLK as a leader and the movement he is known for! We are desperate for a revolution today and I believe it can happen again. This earth will pass away but Gods word remains forever!!! Whay truly matters is all thay will last.

    • Barbara,
      I love how you wrote that, even though the earth as we know it will pass away, “God’s word remains forever!!” Now that’s a truth we can build our lives (and “hard things”) on.
      -Lauren Dunn

  • Bethany

    Wow! That is an amazing story. I wonder how I could never have heard of it as much as my brother and I love to study that time period.

    • Bethany,
      I’m so glad you enjoyed the article! I only heard the story for the first time about two years ago, but there is so much we can learn from it. My brother and I enjoy learning about that time period, too!
      -Lauren Dunn

  • axogrl

    Thank you Lauren for this story. I work as an admin in student ministries. I wonder if any of us(young or old, I am middle aged) could have the courage that the young people and their professor of the White Rose had. Actually, it has haunted me since I read this story. I went to you tube and watched the movie, Sophie Scholl, the Final Days. Watch it, it is very good. One day we will be called for an accounting of our lives. I know I need to do better and hope to never forget this true story of young people who followed their consciences and were willing to face the consequences. Did you know they were executed by guillotine, only 4 days after being arrested.? The French were not the only ones who favored the guillotine. One thing I found is that groups today are using the term white rose for their own movements, but I think it is not in the original intent. These people were following their Christian morals, non violent, and used their words to tell their countrymen of the horrors of a fascist dictator and his evil regime.

    • Axogrl,

      I was so encouraged to hear your thoughts about Hans and Sophie Scholl; I am glad that their story has impacted you as it has me. I have heard of the movie about Sophie Scholl, but I haven’t actually seen it. I did know they were executed by guillotine soon after their arrest (their parents did not know they had been executed until after the fact), but I haven’t heard of people using the term “White Rose” today. Sometimes I wonder how many courageous people in the past have lived and died with most of us never hearing their story. Just think how many amazing stories we will hear in heaven!

      -Lauren

  • Elisabeth Sullivan

    This was so inspiring! They were so brave in the face of death…
    I don’t think I could ever do that…

    • Elisabeth,

      I’m so glad you enjoyed reading the Scholls’ story! There are other things Hans and Sophie said that I didn’t have space for in the article, and here is one example of how Hans described the struggle he faced inside:

      “Where does the truth lie? Should one go off and build a little house with flowers outside the windows and a little garden outside the door, and extol and thank God and turn one’s back on the world and its filth? Isn’t seclusion a form of treachery or desertion? I’m weak and puny, but I want to do what is right.”

      I know it’s daunting to think of what others have done and how we would have responded if we were in their shoes, but I don’t think Hans and Sophie ever expected to be in that kind of situation, either. They just followed God and chose what is right – and faced the consequences, as hard as that was. It’s scary to think of what we could face in the future, but it’s comforting to remember that they were scared, too – and that the God who was with them will always be with us.

      Thanks for reading, and I pray God’s blessings on you as you continue to follow Him!

      -Lauren

      • Elisabeth Sullivan

        Thanks for the encouragement. I really needed it when I read your reply.

        • That’s why I love history. :-)

          “Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight, and sin which clings so closely, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God.” – Hebrews 12:1-2

  • Cecilia

    I know I’m late (by like two years!), but I was really excited to read this. I wrote a college paper on the White Rose last year, and I had so much fun digging through Hans and Sophie’s journal entires. I also watched a recent movie about Sophie Scholl: very interesting and inspiring (although in German…luckily there were English subtitles!).

  • David L. Hagen

    “What can Men do against such reckless hate?
    Ride out with me – ride out to meet them . . .
    Look to my coming – at first light – at dawn look to the east . . .”
    See the Battle of Helmsdeep
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6XicBBN1l4

  • Jeroen

    I just want to point out: there is no God. Never has been, never will be. You are alone responsible for your thoughts and actions. No hiding. Sorry.

Back to Top ↑